Listen

Despite Turkey's Crackdown, Some Critics Are Still Speaking Out

Jul 27, 2016
Originally published on July 27, 2016 4:04 pm

Most critics of the Turkish government have been frightened into silence these days. The country is consumed with rooting out backers of this month's failed coup attempt — an ongoing purge has affected tens of thousands of people.

But it's still possible to find Turks willing to talk about why they oppose both the July 15 coup attempt and President Recep Tayyip Erdogan's aggressive reaction, saying legitimate criticism must not be silenced.

Many outside Turkey were perplexed to see Erdogan respond to the coup attempt not only by purging the military of coup sympathizers, but by instantly dismissing some 20,000 teachers and firing masses of employees in the education ministry.

One person who wasn't surprised is Asli Odman.

A lecturer at Mimar Sinan University, Odman says academics have been feeling the government's wrath for some time now. Earlier this year some 2,000 academics signed a petition calling for an end to the conflict with Kurdish militants in Turkey's southeast. Dozens of signatories were sacked and many were investigated for spreading what the government called terrorist propaganda.

Odman says in a militarized society, no one is safe from eruptions of violence.

"The responsibility of the state is to protect lives," she says. "And it was the irony of history that those generals who bombed cities in the Kurdish regions, and who attacked civilian lives, did the same thing on the Bosporus Bridge."

The bridge was the scene of dramatic clashes with troops opening fire on civilians who heeded Erdogan's call to resist the coup. Odman says the state of emergency declared in the wake of the coup may be raising eyebrows among Turkey's allies abroad. But as far as she's concerned, it's simply an escalation of what the government was up to well before the coup attempt.

"We were just criticizing the state as their citizens, and this is where we are now, in a declared state of emergency, that just ... put the name on what was going on in Turkey since June last year," she says.

Cautious Opposition

Such criticism was missing from Sunday's huge rally in Istanbul, where opposition parties joined in the condemnation of the attempted coup. That rally was organized by the main secular opposition, the Republican People's Party or CHP. Still, some opposition members are worried about where the country seems to be heading.

At an Istanbul tea house not far from the rally site, CHP lawmaker Sezgin Tanrikulu eyes a small glass of strong Turkish tea. A human rights lawyer, he say at first he hoped the opposition's strong support for Erdogan during the coup attempt would lead to a more inclusive, tolerant government.

But he says that's not happening.

"Until you put down the threat of a coup there's some justification for suspending civil rights," he says. "But they need to safeguard the crucial ones – the right to a fair trial, due process – and so far it doesn't look like they will. We have over 13,000 arrested, more than 50,000 dismissed from public sector jobs, and I think there's more to come."

Tanrikulu smiles ruefully when asked if he himself could come under attack for speaking out. He pulls a paper from his jacket. He's just received a summons to appear and give testimony in a case charging him with insulting President Erdogan.

Academic Asli Odman is also facing a criminal investigation. But both say they'll keep fighting for what's left of Turkish democracy.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

RENEE MONTANGE, HOST:

After that failed military coup in Turkey, critics of the government are hunkered down, keeping quiet. And many are scared. Tens of thousands of people accused of involvement in the coup have been detained or lost their jobs. NPR's Peter Kenyon did manage to find a few willing to speak out about the Turkish president's ongoing crackdown.

PETER KENYON, BYLINE: Many outside Turkey were perplexed to see President Recep Tayyip Erdogan respond to the failed coup not only by purging the military of coup sympathizers, but by instantly dismissing some 20,000 teachers and firing masses of employees in the Ministry of Education. One person who wasn't surprised is Asli Odman. A lecturer at Mimar Sinan University, Odman says academics have been feeling the government's wrath for some time now.

Earlier this year, some 2,000 academics signed a petition calling for an end to the conflict with Kurdish militants in Turkey's southeast. Dozens of signatories were sacked, and many were investigated for spreading what the government called terrorist propaganda. Odman says in a militarized society, eruptions of violence can take many forms.

ASLI ODMAN: The responsibility of the state is to protect lives. And it was the irony of history that those generals who bombed cities in the Kurdish regions and who attacked civilian lives did the same thing on the Bosphorus Bridge.

KENYON: The bridge was the scene of dramatic clashes with troops opening fire on civilians. Odman says the state of emergency may be raising eyebrows among Turkey's allies abroad. But as far as she's concerned, it's just an escalation of what the government was up to well before the coup attempt.

ODMAN: We were just criticizing the state as their citizens. And this is how - where we are now, in a declared state of emergency that just - I mean, just put the name on what was going on in Turkey since June last year.

(SOUNDBITE OF PROTEST)

KENYON: Such criticism was missing from Sunday's huge anti-coup rally in Istanbul, where opposition parties joined in the condemnation of the attempted coup. That rally was organized by the main secular opposition, the Republican People's Party or CHP. Still, some opposition members are worried about where the country may be heading.

At an Istanbul tea house not far from the rally site, CHP lawmaker Sezgin Tanrikulu eyes a small glass of strong Turkish tea and says at first, he hoped the opposition's strong support for Erdogan during the coup attempt would lead to a more inclusive, tolerant government. But he says that's not happening.

SEZGIN TANRIKULU: (Through interpreter) Until you put down the threat of a coup, there's some justification for suspending civil rights. But they need to safeguard the crucial ones - the right to a fair trial, due process - and so far it doesn't look like they will. We have over 13,000 arrested, more than 50,000 dismissed from public sector jobs, and I think there's more to come.

KENYON: I asked Tanrikulu if he himself could come under attack for speaking out. He smiles ruefully and pulls a paper from his jacket. He's just received a summons to appear and give testimony in a case charging him with insulting President Erdogan. Academic Asli Odman is also facing a criminal investigation. But both say they'll keep fighting for what's left of Turkish democracy. Peter Kenyon, NPR News, Istanbul. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.