Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Ohio Supreme Court: Are Millions In Public Charter School Dollars Private?

The Ohio Supreme Court will now decide whether a private management company that was paid tens of millions of dollars in tax money to run charter schools is -- at least to some extent -- a public entity. 

M.L. Schultze of member station WKSU in Kent has more on the first day of arguments over how much White Hat Management should have to account for its academic and financial performance.

Ohio’s law says charter schools must be overseen by nonprofit entities, but can be managed by for-profit companies. And over five years, White Hat collected $100 million in state tax money to run 10 such schools in Akron, Cleveland and other Ohio cities. 

The lawyer for the schools, Karen Hockstad, told the high court justices that all was far from well. 
“When the governing boards of these schools questioned why the schools were failing – and the majority of them were within three years’ time, they were rebuffed. White Hat said, ‘It’s none of your business, schools. We’re not going to tell you how we spent the money.’” 
White Hat’s lawyer, David Paragus differed in the description of the tone and some of the details. But he argued that White Hat would have been perfectly within its rights to say just that. 
“The money ceased being public money once it was paid as reasonable compensation for services rendered.” 
In White Hat’s mind, the case is a simple contract dispute – not a wide-ranging question of whether private businesses that make big money from—and carry out—government functions are essentially public entities. 
So when the schools ended their deal with White Hat, Paragus says it made sense for White Hat to claim ownership of most of the equipment and supplies at the school. 
It’s a point on which Justice Paul Pfeifer pressed Paragus. 
“What is in dispute is the property we purchased with our own money to deliver the educational model. 
“Give me an example.” 
“Desks, furniture, computer. 
And you say ‘our own money,’ but it was the state’s money that the schools paid to White Hat.” 
Paragus acknowledged: “That’s correct. And that’s what the court of appeals found. ” 
The justices weren’t letting the school’s attorney, Hockstad, off easy either. Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor noted that each of the schools has a school board. And O’Connor pushed Hockstad on the question of their responsibility. 
“The school board was aware of the failing grades their school was getting. And that didn’t cause them to examine what was going on with White Hat?” 
“It did; there were questions raised all along the way. 
“However, there’s a statute not at issue in this case that was passed a couple years after the contract was signed that says if a governing authority chooses to terminate its management company or even just let a contract expire …, the management company can appeal to the sponsor and have the board members removed and then the management company can put in their own board members so that it’s a more friendly relationship.” 
The case is being watched by charter school advocates and foes throughout Ohio and nationally. But it’s also being watched by other kinds of contractors who make a living from public money but argue for their rights as private businesses. 
The schools’ attorney, Karen Hockstad, maintains they aren’t performing an essential – in Ohio’s case constitutionally mandated public function—teaching kids. 
White Hat operates more than 30 schools in Ohio.

The Statehouse News Bureau was founded in 1980 to provide educational, comprehensive coverage of legislation, elections, issues and other activities surrounding the Statehouse to Ohio's public radio and television stations. To this day, the Bureau remains the only broadcast outlet dedicated to in-depth coverage of state government news and topics of statewide interest. The Bureau is funded througheTech Ohio, and is managed by ideastream. The reporters at the Bureau follow the concerns of the citizens and voters of Ohio, as well as the actions of the Governor, the Ohio General Assembly, the Ohio Supreme Court, and other elected officials. We strive to cover statehouse news, government issues, Ohio politics, and concerns of business, culture and the arts with balance and fairness, and work to present diverse voices and points of view from the Statehouse and throughout Ohio. The three award-winning journalists at the bureau have more than 60 combined years of radio and television experience. They can be heard on National Public Radio and are regular contributors to Morning Edition, All Things Considered and Marketplace. Every weekday, the Statehouse News Bureau produces in-depth news reports forOhio's public radio stations. Those stories are also available on this website, either on the front page or in our archives. Weekly, the Statehouse News Bureau produces a television show from our studios in the Statehouse. The State of Ohio is an unique blend of news, interviews, talk and analysis, and is broadcast on Ohio's public television stations. The Statehouse News Bureau also produces special programming throughout the year, including the Governor's annual State of the State address to the Ohio General Assembly and a five-part year-end review.
Related Content