Listen

Democrats Unveil Legislation To Abolish The Federal Death Penalty

Jan 11, 2021
Originally published on January 11, 2021 5:26 pm

Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Illinois, the incoming chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee, and Rep. Ayanna Pressley, D-Mass., are unveiling legislation that would seek to end federal capital punishment, putting a focus on the issue as their party prepares to take over complete control of Congress, along with the White House.

The Democratic proposal, shared first with NPR, comes as the party will have unified control of Congress after victories in two Georgia Senate races, a change in fortunes for Democratic legislative priorities. The legislation would end capital punishment at the federal level and require the resentencing of all federal inmates on death row.

"There are three lives that hang in the balance this week alone," Pressley said, speaking along with Durbin in an exclusive joint interview. "And this is why we reintroduced this bill this week and are urging Congress to act immediately to pass it. State-sanctioned murder is not justice."

Former Attorney General William Barr announced in July 2019 that the Justice Department would resume federal executions, ending what had been a nearly two-decade hiatus. At the time, Barr and Justice Department officials said they were carrying out the will of judges and juries and providing justice for "staggeringly brutal murders."

The federal government executed 10 prisoners last year, more civilian prisoners than all the states combined over the same period. And more executions are scheduled for the final days of the Trump administration before President-elect Joe Biden takes office.

"Here we are in the closing hours of the Trump administration, when they are in a mad dash to give pardons for federal crimes committed by their friends, and an equally mad dash to try to execute these people who have been on death row for years, if not decades," said Durbin, who will take over as chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee in the coming weeks. "That is just unconscionable."

For his part, Biden has said he wants to work with Congress to pass a law to eliminate capital punishment at the federal level and to "incentivize" states to follow that example.

Last year, transition spokesman T.J. Ducklo told NPR that "the president-elect opposes the death penalty, now and in the future, and as president will work to end its use."

Pressley said she has been in "active conversation" with the Biden-Harris transition team about the issue, and that she is "very optimistic" about the chances for passage of the legislation. Late last year, she led her colleagues in a letter to the incoming administration, calling on it to abolish the death penalty as well as to use executive action to end all federal executions.

"I'm calling on him to use that full authority with the stroke of a pen to halt all federal executions and save lives," Pressley said. "He should also require the Department of Justice to no longer seek the death penalty for future cases, and permanently dismantle the Terre Haute facility where those federal executions take place."

But ultimately, Pressley said, passing the legislation is critical so that the end of capital punishment at the federal level has the force of law, preventing a future president from reinstating it.

Give that the Senate will be divided 50-50, with Vice President-elect Kamala Harris as the tiebreaker, there will still be partisan hurdles to cross. It is unclear whether such a proposal would garner support among House and Senate Republicans.

Durbin said that the Senate will still take up a broader criminal justice reform package.

"The Senate Judiciary Committee, throughout our modern history, has always played a leadership role on issues of the moment," Durbin said. "It really was the focal point of a national conversation on issues of justice. It unfortunately, in the last few years abandoned that role."

Durbin added that he hopes that as chairman, "we can restore the role of this committee in the new Congress on a bipartisan basis."

Support for capital punishment is at its lowest point over the past five decades, according to Gallup polling. While there have been declines in support for the death penalty among Democrats and independents, according to Gallup's historical data, support among Republicans has remained relatively steady.

Pressley said she believes there was a "very significant flashpoint" in the debate over capital punishment when the Justice Department proceeded last month with the execution of Brandon Bernard. Bernard spent more than half of his life on death row for a crime committed when he was 18. In the final days of his life, he pleaded with President Trump to grant him clemency, and his case drew high-profile attention.

Pressley, who introduced similar legislation in 2019, said that she saw an "outpouring" of support for ending federal capital punishment in the days surrounding Bernard's execution.

Durbin also acknowledged changing public sentiment.

"Because of DNA and other methods of investigation, we have discovered that many people who have been sentenced to death were innocent," Durbin said. "One-hundred seventy-three people in the last few years have been exonerated on death row. We got it wrong. The system of justice failed."

One of the longest-standing criticisms of capital punishment is the racial disparities in the United States. Some studies have shown that defendants convicted of killing white victims are sentenced more harshly than those who have killed Black victims.

"While we're in the midst of this national reckoning on racial justice, abolishing the death penalty must be a part of that discourse but also our legislative actions," Pressley said.

Durbin added, "If we truly believe that all lives matter, and Black lives matter, and brown lives matter and the lives of poor people matter, it's time for us to make sure that our system of justice reflects that."

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

To another story now. With Democrats set to control both chambers of Congress and the White House, there's a new push to outlaw the federal death penalty. This comes shortly after the Trump administration revived its use. NPR political reporter Juana Summers has been talking with the two Democratic lawmakers leading this effort. She's here now.

Hey, Juana.

JUANA SUMMERS, BYLINE: Hey there.

KELLY: So who are these two lawmakers, and what exactly are they calling for?

SUMMERS: So this legislation comes from Congresswoman Ayanna Pressley of Massachusetts and Senator Dick Durbin of Illinois. It would end capital punishment at the federal level and require that every person currently on death row be sentenced again. Take a listen to what Durbin told me. And I should note, he is the incoming chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee.

DICK DURBIN: Here we are in the closing hours of the Trump administration, when they are in a mad dash to give pardons for the federal crimes committed for their friends and an equally mad dash to try to execute these people who have been on death row for years, if not decades. That is just unconscionable.

SUMMERS: Now, it's pretty significant that Durbin's one of the people leading this effort and that he's putting a focus on this issue as Democrats prepare to take complete control of Congress. And this, of course, comes after we saw the Trump administration resume federal executions after a 17-year hiatus. Former Attorney General Bill Barr said at the time that the federal government was carrying out the will of the judges and juries and providing justice for, quote, "staggeringly brutal murders."

KELLY: Although, as you noted, Juana, Bill Barr is the former attorney general, and President Trump is about to become the former president of the United States. Where does the incoming president - where does Joe Biden stand on this?

SUMMERS: Yeah. Mary Louise, Biden has said that he wants to work with Congress to pass a law to eliminate capital punishment at the federal level and to incentivize states to follow that example. Congresswoman Pressley says she has talked with the Biden transition team about this issue, and she wants to see Biden act on Day 1.

AYANNA PRESSLEY: President Biden will have the authority, and I'm calling on him to use that full authority with the stroke of a pen to halt all federal executions and save lives. He should also require the DOJ to no longer seek the death penalty for future cases and permanently dismantle the Terre Haute facility where these federal executions take place.

SUMMERS: Now, Pressley told me that executive action on Day 1 is critical. It's also important that this legislation be passed so that a future president doesn't simply opt to reinstate this practice in the future.

KELLY: You know, one criticism of capital punishment is the history of it not being equally applied, the history of racial disparities here in the states. Is that something on these two lawmakers' minds?

SUMMERS: It absolutely is. They both brought it up - the notion that low-income people, Black and brown people are disproportionately killed by the death penalty. Take a listen to what Senator Durbin told me.

DURBIN: If we truly believe that all lives matter and Black lives matter and brown lives matter and the lives of poor people matter, it is time for us to make sure that our system of justice reflects that.

SUMMERS: Congresswoman Pressley made a similar point that this country is in this powerful moment of reckoning on racial justice. And she believes that abolishing capital punishment is a racial justice issue within itself.

KELLY: Pressley and Durbin - again, both Democrats. Are Republicans on board with this?

SUMMERS: Yeah, that remains to be seen. You know, support for capital punishment is at its lowest point over the past five decades, according to Gallup surveys. Both lawmakers say that shift in public sentiment means there may be an opening here. Congressman Presley specifically pointed to what she described as an outpouring of support in the days surrounding the execution of Brandon Bernard last year. You know, he spent more than half of his life on death row for his involvement in the fatal shooting and kidnapping of two youth ministers when he was just 18 years old. He appealed to the president for clemency, but the Justice Department did proceed with that execution.

KELLY: All right. Thank you, Juana.

SUMMERS: Thanks.

KELLY: That's NPR's Juana Summers.

(SOUNDBITE OF JINSANG'S "LEARNING") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.