In 2000, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention declared measles "eliminated" from the United States. But with measles continuing to spread and at times flourish in many parts of the globe, the U.S. has been unable to remain immune to the disease.
This year, the U.S. has its highest number of measles cases in 25 years. As of this week, the CDC has recorded 704 cases in 22 states.
The reemergence of measles is linked to parents who have chosen not to vaccinate their children against this highly contagious disease.
But that's not the full explanation. James Goodson, a senior measles scientist at the CDC, says the U.S. outbreaks are being driven by a surge in measles globally.
The World Health Organization tallied over 112,000 measles cases in the first quarter of 2019. This is up more than 300% compared with the same period in 2018. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, director-general of the WHO, calls the rise in measles "alarming" and a "global crisis."
Madagascar is grappling with a measles outbreak that has sickened 70,000 people and killed more than 1,000. There are also significant outbreaks in Brazil, India, the Philippines, Ukraine and Venezuela. There have been smaller flare-ups in France, Greece, Israel and Georgia.
"When we see large measles outbreaks in countries that are common destinations for U.S. travelers, like we're seeing this year," Goodson says, "that's when we often see the largest number of measles cases in the U.S."
That's because of the nature of the virus. "The only reservoir for the measles virus is people," Goodson says. "So the only way you're going to get measles is if you come in contact with somebody who's infected with measles."
Measles is one of the most highly contagious human diseases known to science. Before a measles vaccine was introduced in the U.S. in the 1960s, the CDC estimates there were 3 million to 4 million cases a year in the country.
Epidemiologists say that to stop the spread of the virus, 95% of people need to be either vaccinated or immune to measles because they already had the disease. In 2000, the WHO launched a campaign to attack measles globally, with the ambitious target of getting 90% of children vaccinated before their first birthday. The WHO at that point wasn't even talking about "eradicating" measles; the goal was simply to "control" it.
The campaign has brought the estimated number of measles cases down from nearly a million a year globally in 2000 to just over 100,000 in 2016. But since then the number has increased dramatically.
"Globally we've made great strides with reducing [measles] incidents by 80 percent since the year 2000," Goodson says. "But we do go through these periods where there are resurgences of measles. It happens, and it's related to people not being vaccinated."
Goodson says there are three basic scenarios globally in which measles ends up with fertile ground to spread.
The first scenario: countries that don't have the health care infrastructure to consistently carry out immunization campaigns. Depending on the formulation, the vaccine needs to be refrigerated — transported and stored at between -58 degrees Fahrenheit and 5 F or between -58 F and 46 F. Either temperature range can be a challenge in tropical countries with spotty electricity. The countries with the lowest vaccination rates also tend to rank as some of the least developed in the world: South Sudan, Chad, Haiti, the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
The second scenario feeding the spread of measles is civil strife. This applies to places like Syria and Venezuela that used to have strong immunization programs. Those systems fell apart because of war or social collapse. And Goodson says this doesn't affect just those individual countries.
"That outbreak in Venezuela has gone on to spread throughout the region of the Americas, infecting countries like Brazil, Chile, Peru," he says. "I could go on and on. Most of the countries in the region have now been affected by that outbreak."
The third scenario fueling outbreaks globally is parents' choosing not to have their kids vaccinated even though vaccines are widely available. These people don't trust that the vaccines are safe, think there are too many vaccines or don't trust the health care system in general.
In 2017, the botched rollout of a dengue vaccine in the Philippines (which turned out to make dengue infections worse in people who'd never had dengue previously) ended up causing vaccination rates to drop for other diseases, including measles.
Dr. Robin Nandy, UNICEF's chief of immunization, says that in some places like Ukraine, several of these scenarios are playing out at the same time.
"Ukraine is a complex situation," Nandy says.
From March 2018 to February 2019, Ukraine recorded 72,408 measles cases, the most of any country in the world.
"They've had trust issues," he says about high levels of skepticism toward vaccines in Ukraine. "Also they've had system breakdowns, vaccine shortages that undermine community confidence toward the health service."
In addition, fighting between the government and pro-Russia separatists has caused some parts of the country to be cut off from others, disrupting lots of government services, including vaccine delivery.
In 2016, according to the WHO, only 42% of kids in Ukraine were vaccinated against measles.
"It is not one cause or one determinant that causes low vaccination rates," Nandy says. "Each country is different. The Philippines and Ukraine are very, very different scenarios, and there are very different reasons why kids in these countries are not vaccinated."
Nandy says the measles virus is a "super-spreader." It can linger in the air in a room or an airplane for hours, waiting to find a new host. If exposed to the virus, 90% of unvaccinated people will end up infected.
But Nandy emphasizes that there's a super-effective vaccine to combat this super-spreader virus. He says the challenge for global health officials is to understand the complex social, economic and structural reasons that are keeping that vaccine from reaching everyone who needs it.
AILSA CHANG, HOST:
The U.S. is dealing with its worst measles outbreak in 25 years, and experts say these cases are fueled by a global surge in the disease. The World Health Organization counted more than 100,000 cases of measles in the first quarter of this year. That figure is up by more than 300%, compared to the same period a year ago. NPR's Jason Beaubien has more.
JASON BEAUBIEN, BYLINE: Dr. James Goodson at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta says the U.S. measles cases are a direct result of the outbreaks abroad.
JAMES GOODSON: When we see large measles outbreaks in other countries that are common destinations for travelers from the U.S., that's when we often see the largest number of measles cases in the U.S. like we're seeing this year.
BEAUBIEN: Madagascar is grappling with a measles outbreak that sickened 70,000 people and killed more than a thousand. Ukraine had a similar number of cases. There are ongoing measles outbreaks in the Philippines, India, Romania, Brazil and Venezuela. There have been smaller flare-ups in popular vacation destinations like France, Greece and Israel. And it's unvaccinated travelers who are the problem. They're the ones who are bringing the virus into the U.S.
GOODSON: The only reservoir for measles virus is people, so the only way you're going to get measles is if you come in contact with somebody who's infected with measles.
BEAUBIEN: For the first few days, someone infected with measles might not even know they're sick. Yet they're spreading the highly contagious airborne virus on the plane, in airports and to other unvaccinated people.
GOODSON: The only way that measles is still surviving today is through transmission through unimmunized people.
BEAUBIEN: To completely stop the spread of measles, epidemiologists say 95% of a community needs to be immune to the disease, yet the global vaccination rate stands at about 87%. The U.S. is at 92% coverage. Some countries have measles immunization rates well below 60%. The reasons for this are varied. Some places simply don't have the resources to refrigerate and distribute vaccines. Others had the resources, like Syria and Venezuela, but lost them in the midst of civil strife. Some places like Romania have seen growing resistance to vaccines. Dr. Robin Nandy, UNICEF's chief of immunization based in New York, says most of these scenarios are playing out in Ukraine.
ROBIN NANDY: The Ukraine is a complex situation.
BEAUBIEN: Over the last 12 months, Ukraine recorded just over 72,000 cases, the most of any country in the world. There's been a very high-profile and vocal anti-vaccination campaign in Ukraine. It's had armed clashes between the government and pro-Russian separatists. Ukrainians report high levels of distrust towards their government, which Nandy says also applies to the health system.
NANDY: They've had, also, systems break down. They've had vaccine shortages that undermine community confidence, you know, towards the health services.
BEAUBIEN: Nandy says the challenge in trying to get global measles vaccination rates up above 95% is that there's no one-size-fits-all solution. And he says the potential for more large measles outbreaks exists right now in many parts of the world.
NANDY: You know, there are countries today with low vaccination coverage who are not having outbreaks, currently. But that doesn't mean that they're not going to have outbreaks tomorrow. They're extremely susceptible to outbreaks at any time.
BEAUBIEN: And if that happens, it increases the chances that there'll be more measles outbreaks here in the United States, too. Jason Beaubien, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.