Texas Voters Are Caught In The Middle Of A Battle Over Mail-In Voting

May 29, 2020
Originally published on May 30, 2020 6:30 pm

In an effort to keep voters safe, states of all political complexions are finding ways to expand access to mail-in ballots as a result of the coronavirus pandemic.

Then there's Texas.

The state has some of the most restrictive laws limiting vote by mail in the country. Under Texas law, the program is open only to people who are 65 or older, people who will be out of the county during the election, people who are in jail and not convicted, and people who are disabled.

And after a series of often-contradictory court orders over the past month, it's still unclear whether more Texans will be able to use mail-in ballots during upcoming elections in July and November.

There are currently multiple legal challenges to those policies working through various state and federal courts. Lower court judges have ordered the state to allow voters greater access to mail-in ballots during the COVID-19 pandemic. Higher courts have routinely overturned those orders – often a day or two later.

The most recent legal decision, made by the Texas Supreme Court on Wednesday, said lack of immunity to the virus was not sufficient grounds for requesting a mail-in ballot.

The legal battles come as President Trump and his allies are seeking to limit the use of mail-in voting, arguing with that the practice is more likely to lead to fraud. Years of studies and research indicate fraud in American elections is extremely rare. Multiple polls show that more than 60% of American voters would like access to mail-in ballots due to the pandemic.

Democrats accuse Republicans of trying to minimize voter turnout because of the belief that Democratic voters would be less likely to cast a ballot in person than GOP supporters.

While courts sort out the legal matter, voters like Leslie Riddel say they are doing what they can to make sure they can safely vote in upcoming elections.

"I just know that my health risk will be increased if I go vote [in person]," Riddel, a 62-year-old former smoker who lives in Austin, said. She applied for a mail-in ballot several weeks ago.

Who is disabled?

Some of the legal disputes are currently over whether voters who are not immune to COVID-19 – which would include almost everyone – qualify for a mail-in ballot under the disability category.

According to the Texas election code, "disability" means "a sickness or physical condition that prevents the voter from appearing at the polling place on election day without a likelihood of needing personal assistance or of injuring the voter's health."

Riddel said she read the election code, weeks before the onslaught of court orders, and was convinced she qualified and decided she wasn't going to vote in-person while the coronavirus continued to spread throughout the state.

"That is injurious to my health," she said. "And that's how I see it."

In most states, polling places are indoors. Voters spend time waiting in line and touching equipment used by others, all factors that could increase the risk of contracting the virus. Wisconsin officials say at least 71 people who went to the polls in person during that state's controversial election last month were later diagnosed with COVID-19.

Texas typically offers more than ten days of in-person early voting that state officials suggest is enough to prevent crowding at polling places.

While voting rights groups in Texas agree with voters like Riddel, state officials don't.

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton says he could prosecute voters who improperly request absentee ballots due to the coronavirus pandemic.
Tony Gutierrez / AP

Voter fraud prosecutions possible

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has said in statements that "fear of contracting COVID-19 does not amount to a sickness or physical condition as required by state law." He also said that his office would prosecute people for voter fraud if they use a mail-in ballot in a matter he said is improper.

"We have to trust voters to do the right thing," Paxton said, "obviously if we found out someone has voted by mail and they have done it fraudulently, my job — just like the Michigan Secretary of State prosecuting voter fraud — my job is exactly the same."

Paxton has a long history of prosecuting voters of alleged voting crimes in the state, which critics have said is an effort to intimidate voters.

Tommy Buser-Clancy, a senior staff attorney with the ACLU of Texas, said Paxton's threats amount to voter suppression.

"It's in line with Attorney General Ken Paxton's overall view that it should be harder and scarier to vote," he said.

Buser-Clancy said voters who are not sure whether they are able to vote by mail should talk to their local election officials.

But those officials are also limited in terms of what they can do.

Voter confusion

Jennifer Anderson, the elections administrator for Hays County south of Austin, said that by law, she has to grant a mail-in ballot to anyone who fills out a form for one. The law doesn't permit election officials to decide whether a voter qualifies for a mail-in ballot.

All the recent court orders haven't made her work "that much different" and Anderson said it's up to voters to "assess their own circumstances."

"So, if somebody selects the qualification of 'disability,' they don't have to explain to us why they made that qualification," Anderson said.

Anderson said she's been hearing from a lot of confused voters in the past few weeks. In the meantime, she is preparing for an uptick in mail-in ballot applications ahead of the next elections.

In Travis County, where Austin is, demand for mail-in ballots is "off the charts," according to county clerk Dana DeBeauvoir, who said "It doesn't compare to anything," that she's seen before.

It's not clear if Paxton actually has the authority to prosecute voters who seek an absentee ballot to avoid coming into contact with the coronavirus.

Leslie Riddel said she's not concerned.

"Bring it on," she said. "He can prosecute me and I will stand my case. I feel I am in the right."

Copyright 2020 KUT 90.5. To see more, visit KUT 90.5.


States throughout the country have expanded voting by mail due to the pandemic but not Texas. As Ashley Lopez of member station KUT reports, voters there are caught in the middle of a messy legal fight over mail-in ballots.

ASHLEY LOPEZ, BYLINE: Leslie Riddel is a 62-year-old self-described former smoker who lives in Austin. She's been self-isolating since early March and, in general, has been taking the pandemic pretty seriously. And several weeks ago, she started thinking about upcoming elections, including one in July. And Riddel came to the conclusion that she should look into voting by mail.

LESLIE RIDDEL: I realized a while back that things were not going to be back to normal anytime soon. So I better get on this and make sure I have this taken care of so that I can vote.

LOPEZ: So Riddel started doing some research. Texas currently has some of the strictest policies about vote by mail in the country. It's mostly only available to people who are over 65, out of town or disabled. And Riddel says she looked up what disability means in the Texas election code.

RIDDEL: And it says if a person has a physical condition and if I go to the polling place - I don't have the exact words in front of me - but that it would lead to injury to my health or it would injure my health.

LOPEZ: And Riddel says that's exactly her situation. She doesn't have immunity to COVID and she's over 60 and smoked most of her life. Riddel says it's clear to her that this applies to her, which is why she applied for a mail-in ballot weeks ago.

RIDDEL: And that's how I see it.

LOPEZ: But Texas officials don't see it that way. They argue voters have plenty of time to vote in-person during early voting. The state's Attorney General Ken Paxton also says the disability category for a mail-in ballot only applies to people with, quote, "actual disabilities that render them unable to vote in person." He's even threatened to prosecute voters. Here's Paxton during a recent interview about this on MSNBC.


KEN PAXTON: Obviously, if we find out somebody has voted by mail and they've done it, fraudulently, my job - just like the Michigan secretary of state talked about prosecuting voter fraud, you know, my job is exactly the same.

LOPEZ: Paxton has a long history of prosecuting people for alleged voting crimes in the state, which critics say is part of a larger effort to intimidate voters. Tommy Buser-Clancy with the ACLU of Texas says these threats amount to voter suppression.

TOMMY BUSER-CLANCY: It's in line with Attorney General Ken Paxton's overall view that it should be harder and scarier to vote.

LOPEZ: Buser-Clancy says voters should be seeking information from the local election officials in Texas who actually administer mail-in ballots. But even they're in a weird position. Right now, there are several lawsuits working through the courts. So far, many of the court orders contradict each other. Travis County Clerk Dana DeBeauvoir in Austin says she's been hearing from a lot of confused voters.

DANA DEBEAUVOIR: I do regret that they have been placed in that situation. That's most unfortunate.

LOPEZ: But DeBeauvoir says when voters ask if they should apply for a mail-in ballot for elections this year, there's only so much she can actually say.

DEBEAUVOIR: And I think the simplest thing we say to voters is, it's a sworn statement. It's your sworn statement, and nothing in the law has changed at all right now.

LOPEZ: But, again, this largely depends on how voters look at the existing law. Local election officials can't ask or investigate why someone is seeking a mail-in ballot, so the risk of possible prosecution is all on voters for now. Leslie Riddel in Austin says she's not worried. If the state attorney general wants to prosecute her for seeking a mail-in ballot, she says bring it on.

RIDDEL: He can prosecute me, and I will stand my case. I feel I am in the right. I feel I'm in the right. That's all there is to it.

LOPEZ: And it's likely Riddel isn't the only voter willing to face prosecution instead of potentially risking their health at a polling site. Dana DeBeauvoir says the number of people recently seeking mail-in ballots in Austin is off the charts.

For NPR News, I'm Ashley Lopez in Austin. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.